The Pie Lady and Company
Welcome to The Pie Lady and Company, a charming café nestled in the heart of West Point, Virginia, at 907 Main St. If you're searching for a delightful dining experience that evokes the warmth of homemade meals, look no further. The Pie Lady specializes in genuine home-cooked food, offering a menu that celebrates the essence of comfort cuisine.
As soon as you step inside, you're greeted by an inviting atmosphere that perfectly captures the essence of a small-town café. The soft background music, complemented by friendly faces from the attentive staff, creates an ambiance that invites you to relax and enjoy your time. Whether you're dining with family or stopping by for a quick takeout meal, the cheerful atmosphere makes every visit special.
The menu is a veritable feast for the senses, featuring dishes that are both scrumptious and generously portioned. You won’t want to miss the signature Chicken and Dumpling Soup, which has been described as “mouthwatering” and will leave you craving more. It's the kind of dish that warms your soul, embodying the essence of down-home cooking.
Another standout item is the breakfast casserole, brimming with flavor and enhanced by crispy hashbrowns—perfect for starting your day on a high note. And if you have a sweet tooth, The Pie Lady’s pastries should not be overlooked. The cinnamon rolls and assorted Danishes (both cheese and cherry) have garnered rave reviews for their delightful flavors, especially the cinnamon roll, which has been highlighted as a must-try treat.
If you’re a fan of pies, you're in for a special treat! With homemade pies like the delightful Coconut Custard Pie, crafted with love and care, you’ll taste the freshness and quality in every bite. Many locals relish the Chicken Salad, so make sure you grab it early as it tends to sell out quickly—proof that good food truly is worth the wait!
Reviews from satisfied customers echo a consistent theme of excellence. Michelle Haskiell praised the elegant atmosphere and excellent service, while Angela commended the authenticity of the pastries, free from the frozen or reheated variety so commonly found elsewhere. The attention to detail, especially concerning food allergies, adds to the personalized experience, making The Pie Lady a thoughtful choice for all diners.
Whether you’re planning a cozy breakfast or looking to cater an event, The Pie Lady and Company delivers outstanding service that you'll remember long after your meal. As Linzy Browne shared, they catered an order for 40 people with remarkable attention to detail, ensuring every request was met with grace and acumen.
In closing, The Pie Lady and Company is not merely a café; it's a heartfelt dining destination where every meal tells a story of home, love, and exquisite flavors. Bring your appetite and your friends, and discover why this gem has become a beloved staple among locals and visitors alike!
34 Reviews
05 Sep 2025
31 Aug 2025
21 Aug 2025
08 Aug 2025
30 Jul 2025
29 Jun 2025
15 Jun 2025
06 Jun 2025
Bar Bonanza Espirall
Cafetería los Moralillos
Rumblings Cafe & Takeaway
Café Jekemir Jesus Del Monte
Join the The Pie Lady and Company Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.